How to Verify an EcoVadis Score Before You Rely On It
EcoVadis ratings appear on more tenders and supplier questionnaires every year. They are useful — and frequently quoted in ways the underlying scorecard does not support.
Send your requirementWhat EcoVadis is, and what it is not
EcoVadis is a buyer-facing sustainability assessment service: a supplier submits evidence, an analyst reviews it, and the company receives a scorecard across four themes — environment, labour and human rights, ethics, and sustainable procurement. It is not a product certification, not a food-safety certificate and not a site audit. It says something about how the company is managed; it says nothing about whether a particular batch of tuna was correctly retorted.
How the score is structured
Each theme is scored, weighted (environment and labour carry the most weight) and combined into an overall score out of 100, which places the company in a band relative to the other assessed companies in its sector. Themes are scored on policies, actions and results reported, which is why a company with strong documentation can outscore a company with stronger operations but weaker reporting.
Verifying a claimed score, in three steps
- Ask for the scorecard file, not a logo. A scorecard shows the assessed legal entity, the assessment scope, the score per theme, the overall score, the medal and the issue and validity dates.
- Check the entity name. The rating belongs to the assessed legal entity. A score achieved by a related company or a parent group does not automatically transfer to the entity you are contracting with.
- Check the validity window. Ratings are valid for a defined period and are reassessed on a cycle; a scorecard that has lapsed is a historical document.
Reading a Silver rating in a tender without over-reading it
Silver places a company in the upper-middle band of its assessed peer group, and it is a reasonable minimum bar for many retail and food-service supplier programmes. It is not a statement that a supply chain is sustainable; it is a statement about assessed management systems and reporting. In a supplier questionnaire, pair it with the food-safety scheme audit (BRCGS or IFS) and the social audit report — the three answer different questions.
What to ask for alongside the scorecard
The corrective-action plan for the lowest-scoring theme, the reporting period the evidence covers, and the entity and site scope. Buyers integrating an ESG requirement into a contract usually want the scorecard plus the action plan, not the score alone.
If you are the supplier being assessed
The score is driven by evidence: written policies, documented actions with dates, and measurable results. Suppliers that treat the questionnaire as an annual paperwork exercise plateau; suppliers that keep the documentation current through the year tend to move up a band at the next assessment.
What Kingstar can show you
- EcoVadis Silver (74/100), held by Xiamen Kingstar Imp. & Exp. Co., Ltd., with the scorecard available for review.
- The complementary evidence behind it: BRCGS, IFS, ISO 22000 and HACCP at production-site level, plus BSCI and SEDEX social audits.
- Packaging and labelling compliance work per destination market, including the EU packaging and packaging-waste requirements our buyers are being audited on.
- A single counterpart for specification, quality documentation and shipment, so supplier questionnaires and ESG files come from one place.
Put this on your next order
Send the product, pack format and destination market. We reply with a specification sheet, a sample Certificate of Analysis, the relevant certificate copies and a lead-time confirmation.
Send your requirementAll buyer answers